You're probably also getting an error if you're using the same account number. "I tryed using the Add Bank function ("Add or Edit Bank account" under the profile link) using the same account # but chose checking instead of savings." If you have both a checking and savings account at your bank, they should each have a different account number (routing number will be the same). If you go to your profile, you should be able to "Add a Bank Account" and just enter in the correct routing and account number for your CHECKING account. Then, when you transfer money to your bank, you should be able to select the correct account. You can either keep both your Savings and Checking accounts in your PP account, or delete your Savings account if you don't plan on every using it with PP anymore.
... View more