Found it - my mistake. It was a single large refund for a transaction that happened in 2011, so I recorded the refund in 2011, even though it technically hit paypal January 1st of 2012. Ugh. Thanks for the response though Snowshoe! Paypal STILL needs to work on making their reports and search functions more useful though. I'm just lucky it was first thing in January and I didn't have to look through all of 2012 adding up my refunds!
... View more