The first instance, you got your money back, move on and don't deal with that seller anymore. The second instance, how did Cabela's find out you had received the item, and did you send it back or pay them for it? If you did send it back or pay them for it, why did you do that instead of telling them to pursue the person that made a purchase with a stolen credit card if they wanted to recoup their losses. I don't think that whatever you had would be considered "stolen goods", the crime that was committed was credit card fraud, not shoplifting. I'm no legal expert, but I don't think they had any legal grounds for coming after you. The third instance, you've just now started the dispute process, let it play out. In my opinion, you have $0 down the drain because of paypal so far.
... View more