In case anyone else has this problem, I did find the solution. Go into tools/recurring payments Click "Create a Subscription Button" Change the "Choose a button topic" to "Automatic Billing" - you should then see some text saying "Website Payments Standard premium services" Click the "Learn More" button You will see some Terms and Conditions telling you what you're signing up for and how much it costs* * Except the link to the costs is broken, but nobody reads T&C's right? Click "Agree and Continue" (hoping that the fees are reasonable) That is it! If you have another go at creating an Automatic Billing button, it should allow you to fully specify and save it.
... View more