OK, I just called Paypal customer service, and the guy was very helpful. He found out that the Paypal payment was sent to an old email address of mine. I don't know why that matters exactly, since it's still the same PayPal account, but he reactivated the old email account and then the payments showed up in my account. Before I listed the auctions, i checked that my ebay and my Paypal accounts had my current email address, but there was one other field where regarding the Paypal payments that had the old email address. Weird and confusing. But at least I have my payments now.
... View more