Worked Pefectly! Thanks Pastor_Martini. The problem is caused by naming all of the menu options the same thing. I had mine all named "Contribution of" and then offered 5 different 'subcription' amounts. I change the menu options to be "Contribution of." and then "Contribution of.." etc... (adding more periods to each menu item name). That was enough for PayPal to recognize them as different names, and the menu works fine now.
... View more