I had this problem and updated all my automatic payments and set my preferred card. HOWEVER even with NEW vendors (that I have never shopped with) I am getting the wrong credit card option showing up, with neither of my other two credit cards selectable. I've deleted cookies, double checked subscriptions and card settings. It makes no sense since all these three credit cards are from the SAME provider. It's purely a PayPal bug and super annoying -- I'm specifically trying to use one credit card because they have rewards for using it through PayPal this quarter, but I can't get it to show up anywhere despite having it set as my preferred payment method on PayPal. I've even then bothered to hit the "add new card" option in the PayPal popup dialog (even though... this card is already in my account) and even THEN it will return to the dialog WITHOUT the preferred card shown as an option (again, all three cards from the same provider, so there should be no issues w.r.t. international conversion or whatever). P.S. I first had this problem when PayPal was charging my company card for autopay recurring payment transactions EVEN THOUGH I had never selected that company card for anything, definitely not preferred card. I checked everything multiple times but in the end, the only way to fix it for sure was to completely remove my company card from PayPal. Their preferred card and "autopay" management is all messed up, super freaking annoying.
... View more