Finally got an answer after days of agent chat. Seems there's a bug at their end and it's because the card I was trying to transfer to wasn't eligible but still showing up as a valid card to send money to. Needed to add a different card and go through the verification game. This was the reply that helped where they admit the bug. Annabelle 9 Jul 2020 8:25 AM I have checked the screenshots that you have sent and normally ineligible debit/credit cards will not show up as your option. It's possible that it is a system glitch. I know your time is important, one way to check for the best appropriate action to your problem is available at our Help Center, you may visit https://www.paypal.com/uk/smarthelp/home.
... View more