Welcome to the PayPal Community and thank you for your post!
I do understand your frustration with this. It sounds like the previous PayPal card you had, may still be linked to your account.
To resolve this, I would suggest you contact our Customer Support. To contact us, simply click here. Alternatively, you can contact us via Facebook https://www.facebook.com/PayPal or Twitter @AskPayPal.
I hope this helps!