cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

SOLVED
New Community Member

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

A sale I made last week was the first where I have encountered this new sales tax issue. eBay does not charge a fee on the sales tax, but PayPal does. Between eBay's USPS calculator being off nearly $12 [I accurately entered box size & I own a postal scale], the eBay fees and the PayPal fees, I am out over $38 on a $150+ item. I will attempt to use local pickup through Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace before I post any new items on eBay. I realize it's a smaller market, but it will be my new first choice for posting. Thanks for the suggestion of Zelle, or similar, for accepting payments.

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

I tell people that all that the time "paypal always free" ha right!

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

 I've been on Ebay for over 22 years.  It gets worse and worse for the consumer

Back in the day you could pay for an item and accept payment however you wanted. Check or even  CASH.

They have locked it down and now it is paypal or nothing.

 

What is this "ZELLE" you are referring to? Is that an acceptable payment option on Ebay sales? 

Please elaborate. Thanks

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

Thank you for your efforts. I pray their is a class action lawsuit against Pay Pal. I have not sold much in  awhile but have been on ebay 22 years and counting. Was shocked to see 2 items sold for same prices but paypal charging me a fee on the sales tax that THEY collected that us as a consumer never asked to be implemented in the first place. Bad enough they charge fee on Shipping cost. 

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

Now eBay puts this out today

 

Once we start collecting tax in these states, you do not need to take any action. There are no extra charges or fees for this service. Prior to these dates, please continue to collect and remit tax in these states and comply with any other applicable requirements they impose.

 

Basically a lie. It's not costing me as much as others, but basically I'm being required to pay part of the sales tax for an item that somebody is buying from me?!? Do you go to the grocery store and buy something and they have to pay part of the sales tax for your candy? Sales tax is supposed to be a certain percentage of the item cost that the BUYER pays, not the seller pay part of.

 

STILL UNACCEPTABLE, PAYPAL!

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

How do we edit this post to remove "solved"?  Anyone know?

 

This question / problem has NOT been solved.  It is being addressed by those posting here; those of us who are frustrated and want an answer as to how this can be legal and acceptable.

 

Do PayPal moderators ever pipe in on this? I have posted very little on PayPal community so not very familiar with how this works.

 

Kudos to those who are bringing this to the attention of their state AG's.  This situation will take more than our complaining here online. Action needs to be taken to stop this thievery.   I am grateful for those of you who sound experienced and can help guide those of us who are novices.  I hope everyone reading this will spread the word and contact their state's AG, consumer affairs divisions, etc.

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

I'm replying to this post because I'm not being allowed to reply to the topic. The problem is that ebay is collecting sales tax on the gross amount of my sale. Then paypal takes their fees off that total amount. This is already wrong because the tax isn't money I'm seeing. Then after I've paid extra in fees on this "extra" amount of my sale, the gross amount of sales tax is deducted. So I pay twice now. First the fee on money I don't get, then the extra I lose because the gross amount on which I paid the extra fee is taken from my balance. I'm in PA. As a private citizen I am not required (actually not even legally allowed) to collect state sales tax. If I sell through a newspaper ad, mailer, or at a flea market, I am not required to collect sales tax. If ebay feels the need to assess sales tax, that's fine. But the buyer should be responsible for the entire cost. The seller shouldn't be penalized. Ebay and paypal need to resolve this so if they add a tax to the amount, the entire amount is deducted prior to paypal levying their fees. The transaction details clearly itemize the amount as sales tax being added, so surely they can handle it differently. Charging me a fee on the tax is clearly wrong, and probably illegal as well. I haven't noted this behavior before because I'm a very occasional seller, not an ebay business. Just someone who wants to get rid of odds 'n' ends sometimes. I just made my first sale in over six months, so I don't think this was happening before or I would have noticed. As a casual seller I'm already hurting when I need to ship as the shipping costs have become horrendous. Now I have to lose more so someone else can pay taxes? This stinks.

Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

You are right, it stinks! And no, it wasn't happening before. EBay was collecting the tax until October 31. As of November 1, they changed it so we are "collecting" it in our PayPal, who then fees us on the total amount. Totally wrong for me to be paying someone else's sales tax!!!
Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

You are not paying someones sales tax the buyer is. What you/we are being charged for is the paypal fee on that tax which is theft by Paypal. There will be a class action lawsuit againt paypal. The practice will be stopped , the lawyers will make millions and paypal customers will get 2 dollars each if that. Total BS
Highlighted
Contributor

Re: Fees being charged for the amount of SALES TAX Ebay is collecting for each sale

This is not a case of sellers paying any sales tax for buyers. This is a case of Ebay being required to collect sales tax in their state, not in everyone else's state. Ebay took it upon itself to collect the sales tax for every state that passed a law taxing internet sales. That by itself isn't a problem, except I am already paying sales tax in my state for non ebay sales which complicates matters a bit. Ebay has no business in collecting sales tax for other states and then passing it along with the gross sales amount to paypal for collection and processing where sellers end up paying .029% on the sales tax. I think it really boils down to Ebay still owning PayPal. When a new seller joins Ebay, Ebay tells PayPal to withhold the sellers fu ds for a period of up to 20 days, until they have met the seller standards of Ebay. So it sounds like Ebay is still in control of PayPal, which is contrary to the government decision for them to break up and be individual companies. Really?? Anyone play monopoly? I hope I made this a bit clearer.